Neopreen Teenkap

Wore these on a 40-degree morning ride and my toes stayed warm the whole time, which never happens. The neoprene actually keeps water out too—got caught in a drizzle and my shoes were dry underneath. Pulling them over the SPD-SL cleats takes a second but it's worth it.

The stretch on these is just right—slid over my cycling shoes without a fight, and the waterproof layer kept my toes bone-dry through a puddle-heavy ride. Surprisingly snug fit even with the cleats underneath, no flapping around.

I've been through three rainy commutes and a brutal headwind since these arrived, and my toes stayed completely dry and warm. The waterproof neoprene doesn't add any bulk, and the slight stretch makes them a cinch to slip over my cycling shoes before I clip in.